Last month's Summit of Francophonie countries held in Quebec City,
Canada, offered an unusual opportunity for Mauritius - and more
than 50 other French-speaking countries - to reflect on the importance
of the French language and culture in their countries.
Is it still relevant, many wondered, to be so closely aligned
with a language and a country that has been losing influence in
a world that is increasingly dominated by English - and more recently
by languages like Mandarin?
Weekend Correspondent Pamela de St. Antoine, accompanied by photographer
Peggy Lampotang, a Mauritian-born resident of Toronto, attended
the Summit in Quebec with the hope of finding answers to these
questions.
All the countries gathered for the "XXIIe Sommet de la Francophonie"
were indeed very proud of their linguistic ties to France. And
the choice of Quebec City as the host was not by chance. At a
time when Quebec is celebrating its 400th anniversary as the first
French settlement in North America, the city symbolizes a broader
effort to defend the French culture and language against the dominance
of English and other emerging languages.
Several red flags of concern were raised about the future of the
French language.
"The French voice has weakened on the world stage,"
Quebec Premier Jean Charest said at the Summit. The promotion
of French is " a battle that we must wage."
"Notre langue est en danger," a dit Abdou Diouf, Secrétaire
Général de la Francophonie.
"Même s'il y a beaucoup de genes qui apprennent le
français dans le monde, même s'il y a une forte demande
pour le français, nous constatons dans les organisations
internationales qu'on a tendance à favoriser l'unilinguisme,"
selon l'ancien président Sénégalais.
And Diouf should know, as experts say the future of the French
language could very well be on the African continent. Teaching
French to African children, many of whom do not now go to school,
could produce several more million French-speakers over the next
20 years. But in order for this to happen, the richer Francophone
countries must invest more in education - a difficult task during
the current global financial crisis.
It may be too late in at least one formerly Francophone country,
however. During the summit, which was held from Oct. 17-19, news
broke that Rwanda, a former Belgian colony and long-standing member
of the Francophonie, would no longer teach French in its schools.
This was partly due to the anger that the now ruling Tutsi leaders
have toward France, which trained and armed the Hutu militia that
carried out the 1994 genocide. The French embassy and cultural
center closed in 2006. But it's also a practical move. English
is the predominant language of business, research and IT, Rwandan
leaders said, and the decision follows other steps already taken
to move the country toward English.
The language of Molière now ranks 9th in the world
Much has been made about the decline of the French culture and
language, with many articles, studies and books examining the
trend.
Statistics show that the language of Molière, once the
predominant language of literature and diplomacy, now ranks 9th
in the world in terms of the number of speakers. Topping the list:
Mandarin with 850 million speakers, English with 600 million,
Hindi and Urdu with 480 million and Spanish with 375 million.
More people speak Arab, Russian, Indonesian and Bengali than they
do French.
In 2007, Time Magazine caused an outrage in France when it ran
a cover story on "The Death of French Culture," The
article was roundly criticized in France but nonetheless it forced
the French to re-examine the status of their culture.
In addition, French is no longer the foreign language of choice
of many of the world's students. In the United States, where teaching
Spanish is overtaking French, the College Board, the national
testing company that produces examinations taken by high school
students, will drop its advanced French literature course beginning
next year due to low enrollment.
The French language also faces competition from several other
fronts.
Mandarin is now the dominant language of the world in terms of
the number of speakers, and China is taking advantage of its emerging
economic influence to also promote its culture and language. Mandarin
is the first language in Asia, and is taught in Taiwan, Singapore,
Malaysia, Thailand, South Korea and Mongolia. As part of its
expansionist agenda, China has established a network of 149 "Confucius
Centers" - similar to the French cultural centers - in some
50 countries around the world, according to Le Soleil newspaper
in Quebec. China is also making economic and social inroads in
Africa, investing heavily in infrastructure projects in many African
countries.
India, another emerging economy with enormous potential and a
large population, is also on a campaign of cultural expansion.
Its diaspora has already settled into 136 countries, including
of course Mauritius, and India connects with these expatriates
through a specially created government ministry. There are as
many as 30 million Indians living around the world.
And since the breakup of the Soviet Union, Russia is stepping
up initiatives to promote its language around the world.
Un pacte linguistique
France and the Francophone world are fighting back - but not with
very big guns. With a diminished power and a small budget small
compared to the competition, the initiatives they can support
are limited. And even at the Quebec summit, where the decline
of French was already a well-known concern among participants,
other topics like the world financial crisis and global warming
dominated the discussions. Some critics complained that the Francophonie
organization is not very Francophone any more, as half of the
55 members don't even use French as their official language.
Nonetheless, French remains the second most important language,
after English, that is used in politics and that is taught in
the world, and it is the only language - along with English -
that is spoken on the five continents.
France continues to subsidize its culture - its filmmaking, theatre
and arts, for example - and it continues to finance a well-placed
network of French schools and Alliances Francaises around the
world. In addition, French products - ranging from wine to haute
couture to fine cuisine - still set the standard for the rest
of the world to emulate.
The province of Quebec continues to be fiercely loyal to its mother
tongue, and keeps the language alive through its schools, literature,
media, culture and politics. Although talk of breaking off into
a separate French-speaking state has softened, there are some
who still think it's the best way to preserve French-speaking
Canada's heritage.
After discussions on more lofty economic and environmental issues,
the Francophonie summit managed to briefly turn to the French
language and pass a resolution sought by Diouf, the secretary
general, to create a "un pacte linguistique." This agreement
challenges Francophonie countries to develop local initiatives
to promote the use of French in their countries and identify how
l'Organisation Internationale de la Francophonie (OIF) can help.
French President Nicholas Sarkozy has also made restoring the
standing of France and its language a priority. His efforts were
given a boost recently when Jean-Marie Gustave Le Clézio
was named winner of the Nobel Prize for Literature.
"A child in Mauritius and Nigeria, a teenager in Nice, a
nomad of the American and African deserts, Jean-Marie Le Clézio
is a citizen of the world, the son of all continents and cultures,"
Sarkozy said. "A great traveler, he embodies the influence
of France, its culture and its values in a globalized world."
But not all Francophone countries have to be exclusively French-speaking
in order to be considered loyal francophones. Mauritius is a prime
example of a country that has successfully navigated both sides
of the linguistic divide between French and English.
As a former British and French colony, the island is a member
of the British Commonwealth and also the Francophonie. Prime Minister
Navin Ramgoolam lead a small delegation to the Quebec summit,
in confirmation that French still plays an important role in the
country's social and political life.
The only country in the world where French is in competition
with English
Despite the Anglo influences on the island since the British ousted
the French in 1810, Mauritius has held onto its French cultural
and linguistic heritage and has even seen an increase in the use
of French.
Although English is used in government and the courts, due to
the British legacy of a parliamentary system of government, French
is more widely spoken. It is also the language of television and
the majority of the newspapers.
This bilingualism has helped Mauritius weather its many economic
hardships because dual languages make the island an attractive
place for foreign businesses and tourists.
Ties to France remain strong, however, due to patterns of immigration
to France, opportunities for university education, and to the
extent of French business investments and trade. France provides
Mauritius with its largest source of financial aid, and over the
years has given funds to computerize the government ministries,
expand roads and build electric power stations, among other projects.
"Mauritius is the only country in the world where French
is in competition with English, and French beats English,"
said Alain Gordon-Gentil, the Mauritian novelist and journalist
who writes in French, has had many of his books published in France,
and speaks fluent English. "We are often used as an example
among the Francophonie.
"When you see the uniformity, and how the English language
is imposing itself on the world, you want to hold on to your roots
and to your language, because diversity is very important,"
he explained in an interview. "It's not just a language,
it's a way of thinking, a way of living."
Gordon-Gentil, who was a member of the Mauritian delegation to
the Summit, said that Mauritius has "a lot more to gain economically
with France, as 60 percent of the tourists are Francophone, and
with trade being so important with France."
But beyond economics, there's an historical and cultural reason
as well. "Just like our other cultural backgrounds, you must
hold onto it (the French heritage)," he said. "It is
part of who we are."