New York - Call it special delivery. The island Mauritius has
been enjoying some unexpected and free publicity on New York City's
famed Broadway, thanks to the One Penny and Two Penny Post Office
Mauritius stamps.
Considered the "crown jewels" of stamp collecting, the
Mauritius stamps are at the center of the plot of a popular play
that ends its two-month run on Broadway on Sunday, Nov. 25.
Called simply, "Mauritius," the play has introduced
thousands of American theatre-goers to the island's history and
location, and to its contributions to the world of philately.
A short walk from Times Square, on 47th Street, the Biltmore theatre's
marquee screams out, MAURITIUS, below the bright lights
and a sign made to look like the ragged edges of a stamp.
It's the first time that there's ever been a Broadway play called
Mauritius, and the first time there's ever been a Broadway play
about the hard-driving world of stamp collecting.
The play is more a story about stamps - their value, their ownership,
and what people would do to get them - than it is a story about
the country of Mauritius. But Mauritius is discussed several times
in the dialogue, with references to the island's location on the
world map, its natural beauty ("they have beautiful beaches,"
says one of the characters) and to historical luminaries like
Labourdonnais. There's a nod to the island's colonial past, with
this line: "The British took it over back when they were
taking things over
" And there's a remark about the
island's importance in the world of stamps: "It was only
the fifth country in the world to issue postage stamps.."
There is also a brief discussion about how U.S. President Franklin
Delano Roosevelt tried to buy one of the stamps, and how the printer
made an error in 1847 and engraved Post Office instead of Post
Paid next to the profile of Queen Victoria. "That was a
spectacular error, and is what makes (the stamps) so valuable."
"What was going on in that man's head when he put the wrong
words on it out there in the middle of the Indian Ocean?"
asks Jackie, one of the principal characters.
Written by American playwright Theresa Rebeck, in her Broadway
debut, the story revolves around two half-sisters, Jackie and
Mary, who each claim ownership of a family stamp collection after
their mother dies.
The collection is given to Jackie as a reward for caring for her
mother during a long struggle with cancer. Short on cash and
ignorant about stamp collecting, Jackie wants to determine how
much the stamps are worth, with the idea of selling them. Mary,
however, has other ideas. Claiming that the stamps were promised
to her by her late grandfather who had collected them, she wants
to keep them as a remembrance, or sell them to a museum.
In the opening scene, Jackie, clutching the stamp album, tentatively
enters the stamp shop of a disinterested dealer, Philip, to ask
for an appraisal. He demands money to even look at them.
Their conversation is overheard by Dennis, an amateur collector,
who offers to look at the stamps. He notices right away that the
collection contains the "crown jewels of philately:"
two Mauritius Post Office stamps. He estimates the value at $6
million. Dennis works for Sterling, wealthy, foul-mouthed and
slimy stamp collector, named who has had a life-long ambition
to own the Post Office stamps. He works with Dennis to con Jackie
out of her share. In the meantime, Jackie does her homework and
realizes that she has acquired some of the most valuable stamps
in the world. As the plot twists and turns, a gun is brandished,
tempers flare, Jackie threatens to burn the Mauritius stamps,
and a few punches are thrown. In the end, we're never sure if
the stamps are authentic.
Herein lies the rub: are the stamps real or fake? What is their
true value? But Rebeck plays with broader themes: How can you
trust what people say? How do you put a value on material goods?
Does wealth buy happiness? At what length will you go to get what
you want?
Reviews of the play by New York theater critics were generally
positive, although some thought the storyline was thin and the
characters were not well developed. One critic called it "the
most talked-about show of the current theatrical season."
Just about every review explained the historical significance
of the Post Office stamps and spoke of the location of Mauritius.
In an interview, Rebeck, the playwright, said that she found inspiration
for the play after coming across pictures of the Post Office stamps
on the Internet.
"I don't know how I landed on that website but they were
auctioning off the stamp collection of a Spanish lord." When
she clicked on the stamps from Mauritius, up popped their value,
and she thought, "Can that be true? The catalogue price
listed them as being worth something like $1.5 million a piece.
I didn't have much information, but I was electrified by the idea
that a stamp could be worth that much."
She expanded her research, reading about the history of precious
stamps and talking to stamp collectors.
"The lore that surrounds them was very moving to me. They
became almost mythic. I found myself failing under their spell
- they're physically beautiful, and they're so frail, and they
have a mysterious and haunting history. I was particularly moved
by the fact that it's the errors or flaws in the stamps that make
them valuable. So the play started with my fascination with those
stamps."
Since the play debuted in New York on Oct. 4, Rebeck said she
has given numerous interviews for U.S. newspapers and television
in which questions are asked about the island of Mauritius. "It's
clear that it is little-known island in America and that people
are interested to know what I know about it," she said.
Rebeck said she recently received a letter from an Indian businessman
working in Mauritius who wanted to bring the play to the island.
"I would love to get myself there," she said, hoping
that a trip to Mauritius could someday be arranged as well a production
of the play with a local cast.
For now, though, Rebeck says she has her sights set on taking
the play to London. There is also interest in the United States
in making it into a film.
As the production closes in New York, however, Air Mauritius and
the Government of Mauritius have lost an excellent opportunity
to capitalize on the play's success and promote Mauritius as an
island vacation destination to Americans unfamiliar with the country.
During the play's seven-week run, a public relations campaign
could have been mounted to promote Mauritius, perhaps using a
catchy phrase like, "Now that you've seen the play Mauritius,
come see the island," but nothing was done.
Such an opportunity could have given Mauritius tourism a "stamp
of approval" in America that would have been very difficult
to achieve under other circumstances.
Mauritius playwright Theresa Rebeck welcomes emails. She can
be contacted at: theresa.rebeck@gmail.com
The Manhattan - Mauritius connection:
Finding information on Mauritius stamps is easy in the Big
Apple
While in New York City to see Mauritius on Broadway, I
undertook an interesting adventure to find out more about what
is known in America about stamps from Mauritius.
And surprisingly, there are many resources and experts here who
know a lot about stamp collecting and more specifically about
stamps from Mauritius.
Nestled inside a handsome former private home on East 35th Street,
the Collector's Club is a treasure trove of information
for stamp lovers. The Club has a monthly meetings about various
topics in philately, such as a recent talk on "U.S.-French
Mail between the Conventions, 1870-74," and it's library
contains a wealth of information about stamps from around the
world. The Club also publishes the bi-monthly Collector's Club
Philatelist, regarded as one of the two best magazines in the
world on stamp collecting.
"Almost all of the Club members know of Mauritius, some
intimately," said Robert Odenweller, Governor of the Club.
"A number of members have stamps from Mauritius, although
not many have the early ones."
The library has two important books concerning Mauritius stamps:
"Classic Mauritius: The Locally Printed Postage Stamps 1847-59"
written by Hiroyuki Kanai, a wealthy Japanese businessman. And
the 1993 catalogue at which Kania's pristine collection was sold
in Geneva by the David Feldman auction house.
Kanai had the unique distinction of being the only private collector
to own six "Post Office" stamps, including an unused
One Penny red and Two Pence blue. He won the highest award in
world competition with his exhibit of Mauritius.
The Post Office or first issue stamps of Mauritius have always
been considered philately's most valuable items.
Kanai's book is a rare and expensive volume that offers vast information
that he collected on Mauritius stamps during his 40 years of collecting
and researching. Other collectors call it an "exceptional
piece of work."
The book offers a detailed history of Mauritius and its postal
history under both French and British rule. He writes about the
background of Joseph Barnard, the Englishman who stowed away on
a ship that landed in Port Louis in 1816 and later started an
engraving business. Barnard produced the famous Post Office Stamps
in 1847 and used by Lady Gomm to send invitations for the governor's
fancy dress ball.
Kania does not believe in the "myth" that Barnard made
an error and printed Post Office and later corrected it to Post
Paid. He cites several sources proving that the Post Office inscription
was not an error.
"The Brunel book (Georges Brunel, "Les Timbres-Poste
de l'ile Maurice," Paris, 1928) was the source of a fiction
that the Post Office stamps were the products of engraving error
and this story has been amusingly modified," Kanai wrote.
"In books of academic interest on Mauritius postage stamps,
such a make-believe story should not really be repeated in the
future."
Kanai's Mauritius collection was sold at the David Feldman auction
in 1993 for a total of $10 million.
Like Kanai, Feldman also discounted the story of the printing
error. "It would appear that in spite of all the legends,
that the wording simply followed that on the handstamps which
had been used by the Mauritius Post Office for nearly 10 years.
Of course the unique inspection and the story surrounding it were
not the only contributions to the rarity and fame of these stamps.
The first example was not discovered until 1864, and each following
discovery was accompanies by great public enthusiasm."
According to the David Feldman auction house, the 1993 auction
set the record for the highest price paid for any item in philately,
when an unidentified lady paid $4 million for the so-called "Bordeaux
cover." A group of Mauritians bought a One Penny unused for
$1.1 million and a two Pence unused for $1.2 million. Those stamps
are now in the Blue Penny Museum in Port Louis.
Also in New York is the Philatelic Foundation, which specializes
in expertizing stamps. Located on West 40th Street in a high-rise
office building across from Bryant Park, experts examine stamps
submitted by clients who want learn more about the history and
value of stamps they acquire.
Expert David Petruzelli talked in an interview about his knowledge
of Mauritius stamps. He called the period of 1847-1850 as the
"great period" for Mauritius stamp making, as these
have become the rarest of stamps produced. These items are especially
prized by collectors because they are produced not in England
but in an island colony.
Both Petruzelli and Odenweller of the Collector's Club served
as consultants to the cast of the Broadway Play, Mauritius, informing
the actors about stamp collecting and the proper way to speak
about and handle stamps. They made sure that the script used correct
stamp collecting language, such as having a set of stamps, not
a panel, or that when referring to the color of a stamp it is
called ink, not dye.
When the cast visited the Collector's Club, Odenweller showed
them a copy of Kanai's book on Mauritius and the Feldman catalogue.
He said they also contacted David Beech, curator of the philatelic
section of the British Library in London which houses the "Tapling
collection" that was assembled in the 1890s and has some
of the Post Office stamps.
"They did a lot of homework," Odenweller said.